Skip to main content

Automated Regulation Update System Documentation

Overview​

This system provides automated updates for fishing regulations from various data sources (APIs, web scraping, file imports). It includes a background job that runs on a schedule to keep regulations up-to-date.

Research Findings​

Available Data Sources​

  1. Fish Rules API ✅

    • Provides fishing regulations via API
    • Website: https://fish.management
    • Offers real-time regulation data
    • May require API key/partnership

  2. State DNR Websites ⚠️

  3. NOAA Fisheries ⚠️

    • No public API for regulations
    • Provides resources and links to state regulations
    • Federal waters regulations available

  4. Federal Databases ❌

    • No centralized federal database for state regulations
    • Each state manages its own regulations

Architecture​

Core Components​

  1. RegulationDataSource - Configuration for each state's data source
  2. RegulationUpdateLog - Tracks each update attempt
  3. RegulationUpdateService - Handles the actual update process
  4. RegulationUpdateJob - Background service that runs on schedule

Data Source Types Supported​

  • API: REST APIs (e.g., Fish Rules API)
  • Web Scraping: HTML page scraping (with ToS compliance)
  • File Import: PDF, CSV, JSON, XML file parsing
  • Manual: Manual data entry (no automation)
  • RSS Feed: RSS feed parsing
  • Email: Email-based updates

Implementation​

1. Register Background Service​

In Program.cs:

// Add HTTP client factory for API calls
builder.Services.AddHttpClient();

// Register regulation update service
builder.Services.AddScoped<RegulationUpdateService>();

// Register background job
builder.Services.AddHostedService<RegulationUpdateJob>();

2. Configure Data Sources​

// Example: Fish Rules API for Michigan
var fishRulesDataSource = new RegulationDataSource
{
    StateId = michiganState.Id,
    SourceName = "Fish Rules API",
    SourceType = DataSourceType.Api,
    ApiUrl = "https://api.fish.management/v1/regulations/michigan",
    ApiKey = "your-api-key", // Store encrypted
    UpdateFrequency = UpdateFrequency.Weekly,
    PreferredUpdateTime = new TimeOnly(2, 0), // 2 AM
    IsActive = true,
    IsEnabled = true,
    TermsOfServiceAccepted = true,
    TermsOfServiceAcceptedDate = DateTime.UtcNow,
    TermsOfServiceUrl = "https://fish.management/terms"
};

// Example: Web scraping for Wisconsin
var wisconsinScrapingSource = new RegulationDataSource
{
    StateId = wisconsinState.Id,
    SourceName = "Wisconsin DNR Website",
    SourceType = DataSourceType.WebScraping,
    ScrapingUrl = "https://dnr.wisconsin.gov/topic/Fishing/regulations",
    UserAgent = "FishingLog App/1.0",
    UpdateFrequency = UpdateFrequency.Monthly,
    RequiresAttribution = true,
    AttributionText = "Data sourced from Wisconsin DNR",
    IsActive = true,
    IsEnabled = true
};

3. Update Schedule​

The RegulationUpdateJob runs every 6 hours and checks which states are due for update based on:

  • UpdateFrequency setting
  • LastSuccessfulUpdate timestamp
  • UpdateIntervalDays (for custom frequency)

4. Error Handling​

  • Tracks consecutive failures
  • Logs all errors with details
  • Can disable data source after too many failures
  • Retry logic can be added

Data Source Configuration Examples​

Fish Rules API​

var fishRulesSource = new RegulationDataSource
{
    StateId = stateId,
    SourceName = "Fish Rules API",
    SourceType = DataSourceType.Api,
    ApiUrl = "https://api.fish.management/v1/regulations/{state}",
    ApiKey = "encrypted-api-key",
    UpdateFrequency = UpdateFrequency.Weekly,
    RateLimitRequestsPerMinute = 60,
    TermsOfServiceAccepted = true
};

Web Scraping (Michigan DNR)​

var michiganScrapingSource = new RegulationDataSource
{
    StateId = michiganState.Id,
    SourceName = "Michigan DNR Fishing Guide",
    SourceType = DataSourceType.WebScraping,
    ScrapingUrl = "https://www.michigan.gov/dnr/managing-resources/laws/fishing",
    ScrapingSelector = ".regulation-table", // CSS selector
    UserAgent = "FishingLog App/1.0",
    UpdateFrequency = UpdateFrequency.Monthly,
    RequiresAttribution = true,
    AttributionText = "Regulations from Michigan DNR"
};

PDF Import​

var pdfSource = new RegulationDataSource
{
    StateId = stateId,
    SourceName = "State Fishing Guide PDF",
    SourceType = DataSourceType.FileImport,
    FileUrl = "https://dnr.state.gov/fishing-guide-2024.pdf",
    FileFormat = "PDF",
    FileParserType = "PDFParser",
    UpdateFrequency = UpdateFrequency.Annually
};

Terms of Service Compliance​

  1. Check ToS: Review each data source's terms of service
  2. Rate Limiting: Respect rate limits
  3. Attribution: Include required attribution
  4. Robots.txt: Check robots.txt for scraping permissions
  5. Contact: Consider contacting agencies for API access

Web Scraping Best Practices​

  • Use appropriate User-Agent headers
  • Respect rate limits (don't overload servers)
  • Cache data appropriately
  • Handle errors gracefully
  • Monitor for website changes

Update Process Flow​

  1. Job Triggered: Background job runs on schedule
  2. Check Due States: Find states due for update
  3. Load Data Source: Get configuration for state
  4. Fetch Data: Call API, scrape website, or download file
  5. Parse Data: Extract regulations from response
  6. Update Database: Create/update regulations
  7. Log Results: Record success/failure in update log
  8. Update Tracking: Update data source last update time

Monitoring​

Update Logs​

Check RegulationUpdateLog table for:

  • Update success/failure rates
  • Data quality scores
  • Error messages
  • Update duration

Data Source Health​

Monitor RegulationDataSource:

  • ConsecutiveFailures - Too many failures may indicate issues
  • LastSuccessfulUpdate - How fresh is the data
  • LastUpdateStatus - Success/failure status

Future Enhancements​

  1. API Partnerships: Partner with Fish Rules or state agencies for official APIs
  2. Machine Learning: Use ML to parse PDFs and HTML more accurately
  3. Change Detection: Detect when regulations change and notify users
  4. Multi-Source: Combine multiple sources for better coverage
  5. Validation: Cross-reference regulations from multiple sources
  6. User Reporting: Allow users to report outdated regulations

Known Limitations​

  1. No Universal API: Each state has different data formats
  2. Web Scraping Fragility: Website changes break scrapers
  3. PDF Parsing: PDFs are difficult to parse accurately
  4. Legal Compliance: Must comply with each source's ToS
  5. Rate Limiting: Must respect API/website rate limits
  1. Start with APIs: Use Fish Rules API where available
  2. Partner with States: Contact state DNRs for official API access
  3. Manual Fallback: Keep manual entry option for critical states
  4. Gradual Automation: Start with a few states, expand gradually
  5. Monitor Closely: Watch for failures and adjust quickly